Maine Silent Film Festival 2023

Railroad Disasters
and
LGBTQ+ Silents

Presented by

www.silentmaine.com
www.harpodeon.com

Railroad Disasters

It is difficult to understand today just what a modern marvel trains were in the early twentieth century. They allowed for speedy travel where once such journeys would have taken many weeks, but trains were also fraught with new and worrying dangers that disaster films were quick to exploit. From short actualities to models and special effects, railroad disasters reached their peak with full-scale train wrecks in the mid-1910s.

The program begins with the 1904 Edison actuality A Railroad Smashup. Smashups began as a sort of carnival sideshow and are the precursor to the demolition derby. In this short, two decommissioned Pennsylvania Railroad engines meet in a head-on collision.

Narrative films were soon to build on the smashup tradition in films such as Un drame sur une locomotive or “A Drama on a Locomotive” from the prolific director of French westerns, Jean Durand, in 1910. Here disaster strikes, in the form of models and stock footage, when two railroad engineers vying for the same woman begin to fight in the train’s cockpit and miss a stop signal, sending them head-long into an on-coming train.

From models we return to full-scale locomotives in 1911’s The Firing of the Patchwork Quilt. Likely a trial-                     

run for The Juggernaut, in this short drama by Hazel Neason, lightning strikes and destroys a trestle over which a train is about to pass and the engineer’s mother must find a way to warn him in time.

The program culminates with Vitagraph’s 1915 “Blue Ribbon” feature, The Juggernaut. The president of a railroad notorious for cutting maintenance and safety measures to maximize profits fights dirty against a lawsuit brought against him by his erstwhile friend and now district attorney while, aboard one of his trains, his daughter unwittingly speeds toward her doom. The climactic wreck scene of The Juggernaut, shot without the use of miniatures or special effects, would be remembered for years in fan and trade magazines.

This is the first time The Juggernaut has been seen in Maine since 1920 and the first time Harpodeon’s 2017 reconstruction—bringing the film as close to how it might have been seen at its premiere as possible—has ever been screened theatrically.

The Case of The Juggernaut

Despite The Juggernaut being one of the most commercially successful films of its era—playing for more than 750 days—and being described by film historian William K. Everson as second only in significance to The Birth of a Nation in 1915, Vitagraph’s                     

railroad disaster film came very close to being entirely lost.

That any of The Juggernaut survives today is thanks to John Griggs. A radio actor by profession, Griggs was also a film collector and very much part of Everson’s circle. Film collecting was not a safe hobby. The prints were only ever rented to exhibitors and remained the property of the studio. Even if the studio had no intention of ever exploiting the film again, police raids of private film collections were frequent.

Griggs had acquired two reels from two different cuts of The Juggernaut: the second reel from the domestic five-reel premier version and the fourth reel from the British release, which had been abbreviated to four reels. Skating on even thinner ice, he not only possessed these “illegal” reels but he made a preservation negative of them. It was just in time as the second reel, especially, was showing advanced signs of degradation and would not have lasted much longer.

From this negative, a very small number of prints were struck—likely fewer than ten. One of these prints he gave to fellow film collector Karl Malkames. On his death in 2010, that print of The Juggernaut was acquired by Harpodeon to serve as the basis of its 2017 reconstruction, which bridges the still-missing material with little- and never-before-seen production and publicity stills along with explanatory text and exact reproductions of dialogue titles.

LGBTQ+ Silents

Modern audience may not realize it, but silent films dealing with LGBTQ+ themes not only exist but are not so unusual. American films did, however, have to contend with censors that were not at all friendly and had to be got around in one of several ways. Gay characters may be hidden behind coding, or excused as a parody, or “what if” scenarios.

From Alice Guy-Blaché, the first female director, comes the first film of the program, Algie the Miner, produced in 1912 by Guy’s own Solax company. Algie is the prototypical example of a coded gay man in the early 1910s. Soft and effeminate, he is out west ostensibly to prove himself a man to win the approval of his fiancée’s father, but it takes little to see how important Algie becomes in his mentor Big Jim’s life and how quickly Big Jim comes to depend on Algie as much as Algie does him.

But gay men were not always disguised. In 1923’s The Soilers, a burlesque of Rex Beach’s much-adapted novel The Spoilers, the cowboy who falls in love with Stan Laurel is anything but coded. Rare in silent cinema, he is explicitly gay, and almost unique, he gets the last laugh.

Trans representation is rare in silent cinema, and most examples that do exist are heavily coded, but what                     

is likely to be the first feature film to deal with trans themes and is certainly the first to address them so explicitly is A Florida Enchantment, which concludes the evening’s program. “A Fantasy of the Everglades,” A Florida Enchantment sees Lillian swallowing a magic seed that transforms her into a man. Taking the name Lawrence, he spurns his erstwhile fiancé Fred and begins courting Bessie. Disbelieving Lawrence’s tale of magical-transformation, Fred swallows a seed himself. It is there that A Florida Enchantment demonstrates the ethos of the time: Lillian, when she was presenting as such, scandalized her aunt but was otherwise allowed to openly court Bessie. Fred, when he turns to Frederica, on the other hand, is condemned by society at large and pursued quite literally to death.

Edith Storey, the star of A Florida Enchantment, was uniquely fitted to role of Lillian/Lawrence. Although studio publicists painted a different picture, when off screen Storey was described as a tomboy who dressed in masculine clothes and preferred to be called Billy.

The Case of A Florida Enchantment

A Florida Enchantment is a product of its era and its extensive use of blackface at once stands out to modern audiences. Of course, blackface was not unusual in films of 1914. Far from it; it was the norm. Outside of so-called “race films”—that is, films with an entirely               

Black cast—Black actors might appear as background extras but almost never interacted with the white leads. Black characters who were part of the principal cast were nearly always performed by white actors in blackface.

Today, we see the racism inherent in this policy, but at the time A Florida Enchantment and other films like it were released, white audiences were accustomed to blackface and saw nothing wrong with it. It is not the case that Black audiences approved of the practice, but while they did object and did protest, the white creators of these films never heard them.

With that said, A Florida Enchantment is an important part of film history in that it features what may be the first emergence of trans representation on the screen.

Though a product of its era, A Florida Enchantment also resonates in our own time. Transphobia is on the rise and trans people are under attack. Legislators are attacking trans rights, libraries are being defunded for including trans material, and drag performers are being threatened with death—even here in Maine. Trans erasure is the goal. There is an ongoing attempt to delegitimize transgenderism by erasing it from history. A Florida Enchantment, a film more than a century old, refutes the claim that transgenderism is without a historical basis.

Our Accompanist, Doug Protsik

Doug learned the art of putting together a score appropriate for silent movies from Danny Patt, who accompanied silent movies in Union, Maine in the 1920s—a time when it was the job of piano players to accompany the films since there was no sound. Since Danny passed away in 1999, Doug has been continuing this tradition performing the “Old Time Piano” style and has scored and performed for countless showings throughout Maine and internationally. This work led to his composing original authentic scores for silent movie restorations for Turner Classic Movies, including titles such as Hitchcock’s The Lodger and Easy Virtue.

Using old sheet music from Danny’s collection, as well as researching at the Bagaduce Music Lending Library in Blue Hill, Maine, his scores attempt to capture the unique flavor with the music as it embellishes the action on screen, in an original and authentic way. Doug also has established a fun aspect to the performances by including “musical jokes” in his scores, challenging the audience to recognize them. All the music is memorized, arranged, and improvised by Doug to allow for a seamless flow from scene to scene. Attending a performance allows for a wonderful musical, as well as an historic and entertaining film experience.